‘Kai the Hitchhiker’ Caleb McGillivary is returned to Union County in 2013 to face charges that he killed Clark attorney Joseph Galfy.
Thomas P. Costello , Asbury Park Press
ELIZABETH, N.J. – A Canadian man who initially gained Internet fame as “Kai, the hatchet-wielding hitchhiker” has been convicted of the 2013 beating death of a prominent Clark attorney in his home.
Caleb “Kai” McGillvary, 30, was found guilty of murder, a first degree crime, Wednesday following a four-week trial before Union County Superior Court Judge Robert Kirsch, acting Union County Prosecutor Michael A. Monahan said in a news release.
The jury deliberated several hours over two days.
A post on the Kai the Hitchhiker Legal Support Facebook page indicates an appeal will be filed. The post indicated McGillvary’s conviction was due to not being able to fully present his case.
Easter Bunny bar brawl: Man in viral Florida bar brawl video is wanted in New Jersey, report says
On May 13, 2013 Joseph Galfy, 73, a land use lawyer, was found dead inside his Starlight Drive home in Clark. When police responded they found Galfy’s partially clothed body prone beside the bed, Union County Assistant Prosecutors Scott Peterson and Jillian Reyes, who handled the case, said in the news release.
An investigation by the Union County Homicide Task Force, led by Prosecutor’s Office Sgt. Johnny Ho and assisted by the Union County Sheriff’s Office and Clark police resulted in large quantitiies of surveillance footage, digital cell phone data and other forms of evidence that identified McGillvary as a suspect in the case, the news release states.
YouTube’s ‘Fantastic Adventures’: Kids were YouTube stars. Now mom is accused of starving, pepper-spraying them, police say
McGillvary was arrested in Philadelphia three days after the killing when a barista working at a coffee shop recognized him and contacted law enforcement, according to the news release.
A police investigation indicated the two men met in Times Square, New York City about a day and half before Galfy’s death.
McGillvary, who is from Canada, gained fame in February 2013 after intervening in an attack on a California utility worker in which he described using a hatchet to fend off the attacker. The YouTube video of the interview has garnered more than 1 million views.
McGillvary’s interview describing the incident went viral, and he was invited to appear on TV with Jimmy Kimmel and others.
Man faces drug charges after viral story: He went viral for buying out a Girl Scout cookie stand. Now he faces federal drug charges
Then on May 12, 2013, McGillvary met Galfy, in Times Square, according to a post on the Kai the Hitchhiker Legal Support Facebook page.
The two men had beers and McGillvary was invited to spend the night in Galfy’s guest room. He woke up hung over the next morning and that night called Galfy to stay in the guest room again, according to the Facebook post.
But when he woke up the next day, allegedly after his beer was drugged, he found Galfy’s partially naked body on top of him, allegedly sexually assaulting him. McGillvary fought Galfy away from him, according to the post.
McGillvary was arrested in Philadelphia a few days later, unaware that Galfy had died from his injuries, according to the Facebook post.
Follow Suzanne Russell on Twitter: @SRussellMyCJ
Read or Share this story: https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2019/04/24/kai-hitchhiker-found-guilty-murder-nj/3565616002/