How We Tested
To test these smoke detectors, we first installed and synced each device with its app. After the initial setup, we ran a “self-test” on each model and navigated around both the iOS and Android versions of the apps to assess usability.
Finally, we used aerosol-sprayed smoke to set each alarm off. We did this twice for every model—once while the phone was connected to WiFi and once when it was not—to see if there was a difference in how quickly notifications were delivered. During these tests, we also evaluated the quality/volume of the alarm, quality of the smartphone notifications, and ease of silencing the detector. Other factors we took into account were interconnectivity, app connectivity, and perceived reliability.
What You Should Know About Smoke & Carbon Monoxide Detectors
Like most smart home devices, smart smoke and carbon monoxide detectors connect to your home’s Wi-Fi and, subsequently, your smartphone. During setup, you’ll be prompted to connect the alarm to your home’s internet network (or its compatible hub, which is connected to the internet).
If and when the alarm goes off, the gadget sends a notification to your smartphone, letting you know there’s smoke or carbon monoxide in your home. This is the main appeal of smart smoke detectors, but some high-end models include additional “smart” features like voice controls via Alexa, weather updates, voice alerts, customizable night lights, and more.
Why does it make sense for smoke alarms be “smart”?
Smoke detectors are a perfect example of a device that benefits from smart functionality. Why? Standard detectors have a few major shortcomings, mainly that they’re not all that useful when you’re not home. If your detectors aren’t connected to the local fire department (which most are not) and a fire starts when no one is home, the alarms simply beep away to no avail. Plus, that’s not to mention the dreaded 3 a.m. low-battery chirps—we could all live without those.
Smart smoke detectors solve both these issues, as they send you smartphone notifications when the alarm goes off and give you a heads up when the battery is low. The “smart” functionality can not only give you peace of mind while you’re away from home, but it can also save you time and energy when it comes to replacing those pesky smoke alarm batteries. Plus, if you ever burn popcorn and accidentally set off your smart alarm, you can quickly silence the detector from its app, saving you from having to grab a chair and climb up there to manually silence it.
Photoelectric vs. Ionization Smoke Detectors
There are three types of smoke detectors you can buy: photoelectric, ionization, and dual-sensor. These terms refer to the technology used to sense smoke.
Photoelectric smoke detectors have a light source that’s pointed into a sensing chamber, and when smoke particles enter the chamber, they reflect light onto the sensor, triggering the alarm. This type of smoke detector is more efficient at sensing fires that begin with a long period of smoldering, according to the U.S. Fire Administration.
On the other hand, ionization smoke detectors have a small amount of radioactive material between two electrically charged plates. This ionizes the air (hence their name) and creates a current that flows between the plates. If smoke particles enter the chamber, it will disrupt the current and activate the alarm. This style of smoke detector will typically sense flaming fires more quickly.
There are also dual-sensor smoke detectors, which use both photoelectric and ionization technology. For comprehensive protection in your home, the U.S. Fire Administration actually recommends dual-sensor detectors, which efficiently sense both types of fires.
What is a smart smoke alarm monitor?
If you already have smoke detectors that you like, you can supplement them with a smart smoke alarm monitor instead of replacing them entirely. These monitors are installed in proximity to your existing smoke detectors—some plug into an electrical outlet, while others are battery-powered—and they’re connected to your home Wi-Fi network.
Monitors essentially “listen” for your smoke and carbon monoxide alarm, and if they hear it going off, they send a smartphone notification to let you know. The installation of these devices is typically simpler, and if you have a large home, it may be more affordable to install a few monitors instead of several smart detectors. However, smart monitors don’t allow you to silence your smoke alarms, and they won’t save you from 2 a.m. low-battery chirps.
Other Smoke and Carbon Monoxide Detectors We Tested
Other Articles You Might Enjoy